US shoppers care far more about when a package arrives than how fast it gets there, according to Project44's annual holiday shopping report—a finding that runs counter to the retail industry's long-standing focus on speed.
Asked to rate five factors in choosing where to shop online, 73% of respondents called on-time delivery very important or absolutely essential, the highest share for any factor. Slow delivery was the least of shoppers' worries, ranking last among six holiday concerns, with 46% placing it at the bottom. Higher shipping costs topped the list, with 32% ranking it first.
To ensure on-time performance, shoppers want visibility. 72% said real-time updates on a package in transit are very or extremely important, and 25% would not shop with a retailer that doesn't offer them. Home delivery remains the preferred option for 76%, while 33% plan to use lockers or pickup points and 29% choose buy-online-pickup-in-store.
"The holiday season is a significant opportunity for retailers to win new revenue and earn loyalty," said Jett McCandless, founder and CEO of Project44. "That starts with seeing the risk before the customer does: the exception, the carrier running behind, the condition the order arrives in. My advice for the next few weeks: promise only the dates the data supports, and act before the customer feels it."
The survey queried 2,470 consumers aged 18 and older worldwide via SurveyMonkey and closed on November 3.
For Chinese sellers targeting the US, the takeaway is clear: predictable last-mile delivery matters more for customer retention than raw speed. If overseas warehouses or last-mile carriers frequently miss deadlines, even the fastest first-mile won't prevent shoppers from remembering the late arrival.
